• Home
  • News
  • Features
  • UN-Sri Lanka
  • International Affairs
  • About Us
  • Archives
  • සිංහල
Search
SriLankaBriefNews, views and analysis of Human Rights & Democratic Governance in Sri Lanka
SriLankaBriefNews, views and analysis of Human Rights & Democratic Governance in Sri Lanka
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
10.3 C
London
Saturday, April 1, 2023
Sign in / Join
Sri Lanka BriefNews, views and analysis of Human Rights & Democratic Governance in Sri Lanka
  • Home
  • News
  • Features
  • UN-Sri Lanka
  • International Affairs
  • About Us
  • Archives
  • සිංහල
type here...
Latest news

Sri Lanka: Proposed “anti-terror” bill set to introduce the death penalty and break existing human rights violations record -ICJ

Sri Lanka: The proposed Anti-Terrorism Bill will make president the law & dissent a crime

Sri Lanka: IMF Loan Risks Eroding Rights- HRW

RTI Commission reserves judgment on info about LTTE members surrendered to army

Sri Lanka HRC issued Guideline for police officers to protect transgender persons

Sri Lanka BriefNews, views and analysis of Human Rights & Democratic Governance in Sri Lanka
  • Home
  • News
  • Features
  • UN-Sri Lanka
  • International Affairs
  • About Us
  • Archives
  • සිංහල
type here...

Sri Lanka War Crimes Resolution Softened Before U.N. Debate

FeaturesUN-Sri Lanka
30/09/2015
Updated: 30/09/2015
By Sri Lanka Brief
Share
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
Pinterest
Email
    COLOMBO | By Shihar Aneez
    An air force officer holds Sri Lanka's national flag as the sun sets at Galle Face Green in Colombo February 2, 2013.  REUTERS/Dinuka Liyanawatte
    An air force officer holds Sri Lanka’s national flag as the sun sets at Galle Face Green in Colombo February 2, 2013.
    Reuters/Dinuka Liyanawatte

    COLOMBO A U.S.-backed resolution at the United Nations that seeks justice for victims of Sri Lanka’s 26-year civil war has been softened to keep its government on board and allay the concerns of powerful neighbor India, sources say.

    The latest draft, expected to be adopted in Geneva on Thursday, fails to specify the powers and role of foreign prosecutors and judges in trying war crimes suspects – a major shortcoming, in the eyes of human rights groups.

    They and some diplomats say that reflects the balancing act needed to keep Sri Lanka’s new reformist leadership on board while making a credible attempt to end a culture of impunity over what the U.N. calls the mass killings of tens of thousands of people by both sides in the final stages of the conflict.

    “Everything now depends on implementation – the text was worded in a very ambiguous way,” said Alan Keenan, Sri Lanka analyst at the International Crisis Group.

    A judicial process with teeth would hold out a realistic prospect of punishment for senior figures in ex-president Mahinda Rajapaksa’s government and military, as well as Tamil Tiger rebels, who waged a bitter final battle in 2009.

    The U.N. has estimated that 40,000 people died, many of them civilians, as government forces tightened the noose around a patch of land on the Jaffna Peninsula where Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) rebels were penned in.

    But the U.S.-led draft agreed with the Sri Lankan government falls short of explicitly meeting a call by the U.N.’s human rights chief for a special court staffed with international judges, prosecutors, lawyers and investigators.

    Such “hybrid” courts have emerged in recent years as a way to deliver justice in places such as East Timor, Kosovo and Sierra Leone against powerful individuals capable of threatening judges or witnesses.

    The text instead vaguely affirms the importance of participation in a Sri Lankan judicial mechanism of “Commonwealth and other foreign judges, defense lawyers, and authorized prosecutors and investigators”.

    John Fisher, Geneva director at Human Rights Watch, said the Sri Lankan government had resisted appointing an independent international prosecutor and a majority of foreign judges.

    “Meaningful foreign participation and international monitoring will be needed to prevent local pressure and intimidation from interfering with a fair judicial process,” he said.

    “SUBSTANCE STILL THERE”

    Sri Lanka argues that President Maithripala Sirisena’s constructive engagement with the U.N. marks a break with the recalcitrance of Rajapaksa, whom he defeated in a presidential election in January.

    Sirisena won backing on Monday from U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry, who endorsed a “credible domestic process” with international support when the two met on the fringes of the U.N. General Assembly in New York.

    How this would work in practice still needs to be hammered out. “In order to ensure credibility, we of course need some kind of international involvement. But it will be decided after the consultation process,” one Sri Lankan official said.

    A source familiar with the drafting discussions said the Sri Lankan government wanted to create the impression the resolution had been watered down to placate the majority Sinhala community that formed Rajapaksa’s power base.

    “The substance is still all there,” said the source, who requested anonymity. The U.S. draft is widely expected to be adopted by consensus at the U.N. Human Rights Council meeting in Geneva.

    A Western diplomat in Colombo and a source at the Tamil National Alliance, an opposition political party, said India had been at the forefront of efforts to ensure there was no full international war crimes probe in Sri Lanka.

    This included lobbying by India to change the description of judges from “international” to “foreign” in the draft resolution, reflecting concerns that India could one day face a similar judicial reckoning in its disputed territory of Kashmir.

    Sources familiar with New Delhi’s thinking flatly reject those suggestions, saying the resolution was worded to reflect Sri Lanka’s concerns about protecting its sovereignty.

    (Additional reporting by Ranga Sirilal, Stephanie Nebehay and Douglas Busvine; editing by Andrew Roche)

    Reuters

    • Tags
    • Accountability
    • Democratic governance
    • HRC30
    • Human Rights
    • OISL
    • rule of law
    • Sri Lanka
    • Tamil rights
    • UNHRC
    • War crimes
    Share
    Facebook
    Twitter
    WhatsApp
    Pinterest
    Email

      Archive

      • March 2023
      • February 2023
      • January 2023
      • December 2022
      • November 2022
      • October 2022

      Latest news

      Features

      Sri Lanka: Proposed “anti-terror” bill set to introduce the death penalty and break existing human rights violations record -ICJ

      Sri Lanka Brief - 31/03/2023
      Features

      Sri Lanka: The proposed Anti-Terrorism Bill will make president the law & dissent a crime

      Sri Lanka Brief - 30/03/2023
      News

      Sri Lanka: IMF Loan Risks Eroding Rights- HRW

      Sri Lanka Brief - 30/03/2023
      News

      RTI Commission reserves judgment on info about LTTE members surrendered to army

      Sri Lanka Brief - 29/03/2023

      Related news

      Features

      Sri Lanka: Proposed “anti-terror” bill set to introduce the death penalty and break existing human rights violations record -ICJ

      Sri Lanka Brief - 31/03/2023
      Features

      Sri Lanka: The proposed Anti-Terrorism Bill will make president the law & dissent a crime

      Sri Lanka Brief - 30/03/2023
      News

      Sri Lanka: IMF Loan Risks Eroding Rights- HRW

      Sri Lanka Brief - 30/03/2023
      News

      RTI Commission reserves judgment on info about LTTE members surrendered to army

      Sri Lanka Brief - 29/03/2023

      Must read

      Features

      Sri Lanka: The proposed Anti-Terrorism Bill will make president the law & dissent a crime

      Sri Lanka Brief - 30/03/2023
      News

      Sri Lanka: IMF Loan Risks Eroding Rights- HRW

      Sri Lanka Brief - 30/03/2023
      News

      RTI Commission reserves judgment on info about LTTE members surrendered to army

      Sri Lanka Brief - 29/03/2023

      Popular categories

      • News12524
      • Features6189
      • UN-Sri Lanka1550
      • Situation Analysis653
      • International231
      • Election Monitoring reports 201519
      • Election Monitoring reports 20192
      Sri Lanka BriefNews, views and analysis of Human Rights & Democratic Governance in Sri Lanka
      Make a Donation
      © 2021 Srilankabrief.org.
      All Rights Reserved.